Current:Home > reviewsStarbucks versus the union: Supreme Court poised to back company over 'Memphis 7' union workers -InfiniteWealth
Starbucks versus the union: Supreme Court poised to back company over 'Memphis 7' union workers
View
Date:2025-04-17 04:18:12
WASHINGTON − The Supreme Court on Tuesday seemed ready to make it harder for workers to get help when they think a company is trying to unfairly stop workers from unionizing.
In a labor battle that began when the Starbucks mega chain fired seven employees at a Memphis coffee shop in 2022, the company seemed to have the upper hand during oral arguments before a conservative supermajority at the Supreme Court.
A majority of justices appeared to want to make it harder for judges to force companies to rehire workers who think they have been improperly fired. That would be a setback for the labor movement at a time when it is winning high-profile victories, like the landmark unionization at Volkswagen in Tennessee last week.
"In all sorts of alphabet soup agencies, we don't do this," said Justice Neil Gorsuch, referring to the National Labor Relations Board and its role in regulating union battles with companies. "District courts apply the 'likelihood of success' test as we normally conceive it. So why is this particular statutory regime different than so many others?"
Austin Raynor, the Justice Department lawyer representing the NLRB, said Congress set a limited role for courts because lawmakers didn’t want “wide-ranging district court involvement in labor disputes.”
Prep for the polls: See who is running for president and compare where they stand on key issues in our Voter Guide
“We’re not disputing that it is a check,” he said. “The only question is to what extent it should be a check.”
Coming upThe miscarriage was inevitable. Could she have had an ER abortion? Supreme Court to decide
The court’s focus on labor unions, whose power in the workplace had dwindled for decades after peaking in the 1950s, comes amid an aggressive push by President Joe Biden to revive the role unions. Unions have seen big victories recently in the auto industry, in organizing of health-care workers, and in regaining popularity among workers.
Starbucks union fight began in Buffalo
The Supreme Court was asked to weigh in by Starbucks which has been battling with unions since workers in Buffalo, N.Y., voted to organize a shop in 2021.
In the firing of the Tennessee Starbucks workers who become known in union lore at the 'Memphis 7,' a group of baristas and supervisors claimed they were sacked as retaliation for trying to organize a union. The union filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board, the government agency that monitors union and company relations.
Starbucks said the workers were fired for violating company rules, including when they invited a news crew into a closed coffee shop without authorization.
A district judge ordered Starbucks to rehire the workers while the charges are being adjudicated.
Starbucks argues judges too often defer to the NLRB and the Supreme Court should require a standard that takes more factors into account.
“They should have to prove their case like any other party,” Lisa Blatt, who represented Starbucks, told the Supreme Court.
'Not sounding like a huge problem'
Blatt got the most pushback from Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, who repeatedly emphasized that the court intervention process was set up by Congress, so it has a different function than a typical court injunction.
Jackson also noted that the NLRB receives an average of 20,000 complaints of unfair labor charges each year but asked the court to intervene only seven times last year.
“This is not sounding like a huge problem,” Jackson said.
No matter how often the court intervenes, Starbucks’ attorney said, there should be a “level playing field.”
The NRLB may decide soon whether all the actions Starbucks took in Memphis that a court ordered them to reverse were, in fact, improper. If the board does so before the Supreme Court decides the case, that would make the court invention that Starbucks is challenging no longer an issue.
If that happens, the government will argue the Supreme Court should not decide this case, which would prevent a ruling that would apply to all future cases.
veryGood! (2315)
Related
- Nevada attorney general revives 2020 fake electors case
- Biden administration picks Maryland for new FBI headquarters, AP sources say
- Handful of Virginia races that will determine Democratic edge in both chambers remain uncalled
- A November meteor shower could be spectacular. Here's when to watch and where to look.
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- Drivers are more likely to hit deer this time of year: When, where it's most likely to happen
- Krispy Kreme wants to gift you a dozen donuts on World Kindness Day. No strings attached.
- Mexican president wants to force private freight rail companies to schedule passenger service
- A Mississippi company is sentenced for mislabeling cheap seafood as premium local fish
- Texas inmate who says death sentence based on false expert testimony faces execution
Ranking
- Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
- JJ McCarthy won't get my Heisman Trophy vote during Michigan cheating scandal
- National Zoo’s giant pandas fly home amid uncertainty about future panda exchanges
- Kim Kardashian Proves She's a Rare Gem With Blinding Diamond Look
- How to watch the 'Blue Bloods' Season 14 finale: Final episode premiere date, cast
- Colorado funeral home owners arrested following the discovery of 189 decaying bodies
- Santa Fe voters approve tax on mansions as housing prices soar
- Disney reports sharp profit growth in the fourth quarter; shares rise
Recommendation
Which apps offer encrypted messaging? How to switch and what to know after feds’ warning
Report: Michigan says Rutgers, Ohio State shared its signs before 2022 Big Ten title game
Author Luis Mateo Díez wins Cervantes Prize, the Spanish-speaking world's top literary honor
Russia, Iran, China likely to engage in new election interference efforts, Microsoft analysis finds
At site of suspected mass killings, Syrians recall horrors, hope for answers
Bear attack suspected after college student found dead on mountain in Japan
Jeff Bezos' new home 'Billionaire Bunker' island outside Miami has a rich history ‒ literally
Atlanta man arrested with gun near U.S. Capitol faces numerous charges